Motorboat Monday: A Fond Final Farewell for the HSS Discovery

Stena_Discovery_01
Battlestar Galactica. That’s what I thought she looked like as we sat on the dockside in our coach, awaiting to board the Stena Discovery. It was a college trip to Amsterdam, it was the year 2000 and I was making my first trip on this incredible craft. It looked like no other vessel I had ever seen, more spacecraft than seacraft. I immediately knew I was going to like her.
But now the HSS Discovery is no more. The High Speed Ship may have been fast, but she was still overtaken by global economics. With this post we pay tribute to the passing of an engineering marvel right up there with Concorde and the Lego Technic Unimog.

9107590j
The HSS Discovery was enormous. At 415′ long by 131′ wide, the HSS ferries were the world’s biggest passenger catamarans. She could carry 1500 gobsmacked passengers and around 375 cars. Using brute force, she cut the crossing time on the 127 mile Harwich to Hoek Van Holland route by half, through the simple expedient of being able to cruise at 41 knots.
HSSStenaVoyager_Interior12_100306
I will never forget my first crossing on the Discovery. I remember the sound of the turbines first winding into life before cast-off, then feeling the second phase of acceleration once we left the speed-limited estuary and really starting to fly. I remember the North Sea having a bit of a chop to it, enough to cause the local powerboats to struggle in the swell. There was a Fairline Phantom 38 ploughing its way through the waves, nominally quite a quick boat for its size and it was certainly making 25 knots worth of wake, but then we came up in the Discovery and passed as if it were standing still.
Meanwhile I was sitting in an extremely comfortable chair, drinking a very well made Cappucino.
24zg6sl
The wizardry behind this extraordinary turn of speed was found in the guise of four gas turbines, two big ones and two really big ones, running via enormous KaMeWa waterjets. There were two General Electric LM1600s, marinized versions of the F404 engine as found in the F/A18 hornet and good for 20,000 shaft horse power a piece. That’s quite a lot, but nothing compared to the two LM2500s also fitted. These behemoths are based on the CF6 high-bypass turbofan as found on Boeing 747s. 33,000shp, if you’re asking.
IMG_2084
She could do 24 knots on just the smaller engines, 32 on just the big ones. Running all four takes you beyond 40 knots. Unladen her record was 51kts. Ridiculously fast.
Of course, for an operator, having a ship as magnificent as this is pointless unless it makes you money, and ultimately that was something that the Discovery eventually found herself unable to do sufficiently well. The same was true of her Stena Voyager sister. Everybody loved the extra speed of the services and HSS crossings weren’t priced a lot higher than on conventional ferries. OK, Stena Line could fit more crossings in per day, but factor in the increased price of fuel as time went by and the profit margins just weren’t big enough. The Discovery was taken out of service by Stena in 2007.
800px-HSS_Discovery_front
She was sold to be operated under the Ferrymar brand and went Venezuela where presumably cheaper fuel was available, but only served briefly and moved again to Curacao. Here she was laid up awaiting further trade but found herself in legal quagmire over allegations of “irregulatory trade of diesel from the ballast tanks”.
The next step was inevitable and was the same doom that meets anything made out of metal. There always comes a time where the value of the material that something is built from exceeds the value it has as a going concern. Over ten thousand tonnes of mixed metals were involved in building the Discovery, and nineteen years later on they were ready to be used in building something else. This is known only too well by Stena who commissioned the HSS series in the first place; sister vessel Stena Voyager was demolished and recycled in 2013 at Stena’s own facility.
11881757_796758783776628_648385108_n
The Discovery’s last voyage wasn’t under her own power. She was towed an enormous distance to Aliaga, Turkey, where she would meat the same fate as so many high-speed ferries, albeit none quite her scale. Soon she would find herself beached, then the gas axes would join in concert to reduce her to parts small enough for the smelter.
11917998_1632905800331702_1488812982_n
This photo was taken in August and I doubt very much that there’s anything much left. Which leads me to contemplate where high-speed marine travel goes from here. If the HSS series has been ultimately stymied by running costs, despite being the most advanced, efficient ships they could possibly have been, what chance have we of ever seeing a true replacement?
Ironically, had today’s lower fuel prices and far lower scrap values been the case seven years ago I doubt the HSS Series would have seen the breakers torches quite so soon.
(All photographs stolen from various corners of the internet via Google Search. Please contact us if you’re cross)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 64 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop files here

  1. dukeisduke Avatar
    dukeisduke

    What is the competition for ships like this? Aircraft?

    1. wunno sev Avatar
      wunno sev

      slower ships, probably
      same as the competition for the Concorde was slower planes. we still haven’t built any passenger jets remotely that fast since.
      i guess a factor of 2 reduction in time really isn’t worth the cost, and the concorde established that there would be no need to make faster, more expensive intercontinental transportation unless we could get an order of magnitude reduction in times. instead, planes have been getting way more efficient over the years.

      1. Sjalabais Avatar
        Sjalabais

        The concept is not entirely dead yet:
        http://1.vgc.no/drpublish/images/article/2009/09/14/22339944/1/990/1704668.jpg
        (Also still waiting if my St Petersburg hydrofoil-proposal is of interest)

    2. AlexG55 Avatar
      AlexG55

      On this route, also trains. London-Brussels by Eurostar is 3 hours, then a lot of places are within a couple of hours of Brussels by Thalys or ICE.

  2. Tiller188 Avatar
    Tiller188

    I’d never heard of the company KaMeWa before. I’m not even a DBZ fan, but now knowing that name, I can’t help picturing myself at the helm of this machine, hearing the four turbines spool up, feeling the whole massive vessel shaking, and then shoving the throttles forward while yelling “KaMeWa…..Meeee….WAAAAA!”
    …and then feeling rather silly as the ferry gradually built speed and motored away from her berth.

  3. Tanshanomi Avatar

    While we’re being sad about lost Channel awesomosity, my parents got to make the crossing on an SR.N4 in ’87. I am forever jealous.
    http://foersom.com/org/image/2000-09-17_05_CalaisHovercraft_s3.jpg

    1. Rust-MyEnemy Avatar

      That’s a pleasure which evaded me too. I’ve used the smaller hovercraft between Southport and Ryde, but it uses dreary old internal combustion . Real hovercraft are Proteus Powered.

  4. Manic_King Avatar
    Manic_King

    How about the fastest non-catamaran big car ferry?
    “At the time of her delivery, Finnjet was the fastest, longest and largest car ferry in the world, and the only one powered by gas turbines. At the point of her scrapping in 2008, she remained the fastest conventional ferry in the world, with a recorded top speed of 33.5 knots (62.0 km/h; 38.6 mph).”
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GTS_Finnjet

    1. Dean Bigglesworth Avatar
      Dean Bigglesworth

      Despite major differences, they are quite similar as they both run gas turbines and have a capacity of around 1500 passengers and 380 cars each.
      I’ve been on the GTS Finnjet several times, mostly on the Helsinki – Travemunde route, the last time was in 2001. The Helsinki – Travemunde route took 22.5 hours in summer running at 30 knots, and 36 hours in winter at 18.5 knots using the diesel generators. Running the generators used 50% of the fuel compared to running the gas turbines at below full power, but it still wasn’t enough to keep it profitable.
      Incidentally both the Finnjet and the Discovery were built in Finland, back when the docks were actually profitable and owned by Finnish companies. Now most docks are either shut down, or barely operating at a profit and owned by Koreans / Russians.

      1. Manic_King Avatar
        Manic_King

        There’s salesman story related to the Finnjet one Finn told me 15 years ago: while drinking on the Finnjet, some low level sales guy from Enso managed to “sell” the ship to rep.’s of rich German co. The Germans really thought they’ve purchased the ship, made all the documents ready and wanted to sign them with Enso only to find out that guy they’ve met was random joker and sale was more of a “I’ve got this bridge to sell you” variety..
        Sales guy got the boot though and Enso spent some time and money to get this episode fixed.

  5. AlexG55 Avatar
    AlexG55

    There are plenty of high-speed catamarans still around that are just as fast and almost as big- here’s the 112m Norman Arrow, now renamed KatExpress 1:
    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/fb/LD_Lines_Norman_Arrow_at_Le_Havre_ferry_terminal.jpg/1280px-LD_Lines_Norman_Arrow_at_Le_Havre_ferry_terminal.jpg
    Plus there’s the trimaran Benchijigua Express in service in the Canary Islands:
    http://www.saltwaterpr.com/Content/Story/2015/Large/BM_BenchijiguaExpress_01_m.jpg
    None of these are turbine-powered, though. I wonder if they have a more efficient hull shape than Discovery.

  6. Rover 1 Avatar
    Rover 1

    I hate it when the future arrives and it is better and faster but temporarily too expensive and we have to go back to the past because of accountants.

    1. Sjalabais Avatar
      Sjalabais

      Sometimes, “temporarily” and “permanently” carry much the same meaning, too.
      http://toptenplus.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Transrapid-08.jpg
      My excellent qualifications from playing Railroad Tycoon confirm: NIMBYISM, futurofobia and cost issues make a transition from old school railroads to maglev almost insurmountable. Jess.

  7. Johnsmith208 Avatar
    Johnsmith208

    So sad. They halved the traveling time from GB to NL and we thought it was the future.